Suggestion Question: Cloudy Moon Crone's Dome, 47.2-57.7 buds, A Distinctive Lack of Vincent

[Crabislav]

http://backpack.tf/vote/id/516033dd4bd7b86f7f000007

 

How come Scorching is above Moon on a Haloween-themed hat with a fitting Halloween effect? I never agreed with unusual prices here but people cashing out and asking for just 55 pure is not a valid argument to reduce the price THAT much (not even going to mention "no good offers, price down", as I see this is considered as valid proof here). The thing is that the suggestor (Long218) never  knew what kind of offers I had on my Clean Moon Modest / Moon Wraith etc. and valued offers in accordance with bp.tf prices. 

 

http://www.tf2outpost.com/trade/9559552

-Offer of Moon Wraith + Scorching Anger (sold my moon wraith for Clean lvl12 Moon Modest + Clean Burning Nano + 4 buds http://puu.sh/2BUyL.png . Later had an offer of Clean Burning Bicorne (http://puu.sh/2wXme , dupes go for solid 15+, later Eat the Meek stated he had offers of 20+ but I never checked) + Burning Fukaamigasa + Stormy Storm Tough Stuff Muffs on that Clean Moon Modest what makes it around 43 mxied iirc, rejected. Now calculate what the Moon Wraith is worth.)

-Offer of Harvest Modest, easily rejected

-Offer of Skull Dome + Peace TC + 5 buds, rejected.

http://www.tf2outpost.com/trade/9090354

-Same guy offered Moon Wraith (see above) + Scorching Anger (1 on the market, no offers) + 7 pure (accepted at first, later rejected)

http://www.tf2outpost.com/trade/8634406

-Offer of Clean Moon Modest + Green Energy Crone's (~ 70 buds in sum I guess according to the offers on Modest; rejected but later the guy bought Moon Dome for exaclty the same items)

-Offer of Moon Cannonball (owner was asking for 45 pure, had offers of Burning Hazmat multiple times and rejected) + Moon Jefe + Smoking Veil + sweets (rejected)

http://www.tf2outpost.com/trade/9644743

-Offer of Skull Dome + 8 buds + Moon Mining Light (nearly 60 mixed, easily rejected)

 

Each owner received an offer of Duped Secret TC / Duped Secret TC + sweets, everyone rejected. This alone should be enough in my opinion. I can do a further research if needed.

 

Please note that none of the offers above was taken. So I can say for sure that Moon Dome is nowhere close to 40 or even 50 buds. 

 

P.S: yes, I own Cloudy Moon Crone's Dome, and I do not agree with the suggestion that took someone 5 minutes to make.

[jjjon123]

Moved to general website suggestions

[Crabislav]

Missed the section, my bad, thank you.

[Distinctively Vincent]

100% positive votes supported by solid trades. If you think a different price range is in order, make a new suggestion.

[Crabislav]

100% positive votes supported by solid trades. If you think a different price range is in order, make a new suggestion.

1. I can't make a suggestion because "Your backpack value is too low".

2. Regarding 100% positive votes http://forums.backpack.tf/index.php?/topic/457-unusual-suggestions-coincedence/ . Moreover, I can say for sure none of those 20 voters had at least 10 buds in their backpacks.

3. None of the trades were solid since the suggestor valued the offers in absolutely wrong way and I've proven this.

4. As I can't make a suggestion, I'm unlocking the thread for a further discussion.

[Distinctively Vincent]

It was an open and shut case, there's nothing to question on my decision. If you think there's new information for a new suggestion, make one. If you can't make one, ask someone to do so here.

 

http://forums.backpack.tf/index.php?/topic/18-psa-unusual-price-update-request-thread/